International

Israeli PM to warn Obama not to trust Iran's diplomatic 'sweet talk'

Benjamin Netanyahu will urge U.S. president to not ease sanctions on Iran during meeting Monday

Netanyahu points to a chart from last year in a U.N. General Assembly speech warning about the Iranian nuclear program.
Mario Tama/AFP/Getty Images

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu will warn President Barack Obama at a meeting on Monday that Iran's diplomatic "sweet talk" cannot be trusted and will urge him to pressure Tehran to prevent it from being able to make a nuclear bomb.

While Obama will attempt to reassure Netanyahu that he will not act prematurely to ease sanctions on Iran, signs of a U.S.-Iranian thaw have rattled Israel and could make for a tense encounter between the two leaders, who have not always seen eye to eye on the Iranian nuclear dispute.

They will meet at the White House three days after Obama and Iranian President Hassan Rouhani spoke by telephone — the highest-level contact between the countries in more than three decades — fueling hopes for a resolution of the decade-old Iranian nuclear standoff.

"Netanyahu does not care that he is the only one ruining the party," an Israeli official said.

Obama is expected to voice sympathy for Israel's skepticism about Iran, its archfoe, but will make clear his determination to test Rouhani's intentions and will press Netanyahu for time to do so, U.S. officials say.

For his part, Netanyahu will tell Obama that tough economic sanctions have succeeded in forcing Iran back to the negotiating table and "they should not be eased — quite the contrary, they should be tightened," a second Israeli official said.

Netanyahu will urge Obama to reject any deal that calls for concessions by the West and instead demand specific steps by Iran, including shutting down its uranium-enrichment and plutonium projects and shipping out its stocks of fissile material.

"He will tell the president, better no deal than a bad deal," the official said.

The Obama administration has been vague about what concessions it wants from Iran, and a source close to the White House said the president is expected to resist Israeli pressure for a specific time limit for diplomacy to produce an agreement.

Despite their differences behind closed doors, Obama and Netanyahu are expected to try to project the appearance of unity. Talks were due to begin in the Oval Office at 11:15 a.m. Eastern time, ending with statements to a small pool of journalists, followed by a working lunch.

Netanyahu spent Sunday holed up at his New York hotel working on a speech he will deliver at the United Nations on Tuesday while his aides refrained from their usual Sunday television interviews with the Israeli media.

"I will speak the truth. Facts must be stated in the face of the sweet talk and the blitz of smiles," Netanyahu said at the airport in Tel Aviv before departing for the United States.

History of strained ties

Obama and Netanyahu have a history of difficult encounters, including a blowup in the Oval Office in 2011 when Netanyahu famously lectured the president on Jewish history.

Iran strategy has strained relations between them before, most notably last year when Netanyahu issued veiled criticism of U.S. pressure on Israel not to launch a pre-emptive attack on Iran's nuclear sites.

Having secured a second term, Obama visited Israel in March, where he eased personal tensions with Netanyahu and offered reassurances that the United States was determined to deny Iran the means to make a nuclear bomb — which Tehran denies it is seeking.

But different clocks tick for the two allies. While they agree that Tehran could make its first nuclear device in months if it were intent on doing so, Israel publicly warned last week that this gap could shrink to weeks, thanks to new Iranian uranium centrifuges.

Limited in conventional military clout, Israel, believed to possess the Middle East's only nuclear arsenal, would prefer to see the United States, as a superpower, lead the way militarily against Iran if diplomacy fails.

Yet Israelis watched worriedly as Obama stumbled in his bid to muster domestic support for attacking Syria over Damascus' suspected use of chemical weapons on Aug. 21.

Netanyahu will be looking for proof of Obama's commitment to confronting Tehran with what the hawkish Israeli premier calls a "credible military threat." Obama has insisted he is not bluffing, though he has not been as explicit as Netanyahu wants.

However, Netanyahu does not look any closer to launching a strike on Iran alone, with Israeli public support lacking and questions about whether it would be militarily effective.

In the meantime, Obama's engagement with Iran could be limited by the influence of the pro-Israel lobby in Washington and lawmakers who share Netanyahu's suspicion of Rouhani, a moderate cleric who took office in August. Netanyahu could meet supporters on Capitol Hill as he normally does on U.S. visits.

Seeking to stress  Obama and Netanyahu's common ground, U.S. National Security Adviser Susan Rice told CNN on Sunday the United States, Israel and other allies "have been largely united in agreeing on the process going forward" regarding Iran.

But she acknowledged that the path was unclear, since negotiations with Iran were not yet under way.

Further complicating matters is Obama's reinvigorated push for a peace deal between Israel and the Palestinians in talks that restarted earlier this year. Middle East diplomacy is expected to figure more prominently in Monday's meeting than originally thought, after Obama listed it as a top priority in his address to the United Nations on Tuesday.

Reuters

HISTORY OF STRAINED TIES

Obama and Netanyahu have a history of difficult encounters, 

including a blowup in the Oval Office in 2011 when Netanyahu 

famously lectured the president on Jewish history.

Iran strategy has strained relations between them before, 

most notably last year when Netanyahu issued veiled criticism of 

U.S. pressure on Israel not to launch its own pre-emptive attack 

on Iran's nuclear sites.

Having secured a second term, Obama visited Israel in March, 

where he eased a personal rift with Netanyahu and offered  

reassurances that he was determined to deny Iran the means to 

make a bomb, something that Tehran denies it is seeking.

But different clocks tick for the two allies. While they 

agree that Tehran could make its first nuclear device in months 

if it were intent on doing so, Israel publicly warned last week 

that this gap could shrink to weeks, thanks to new Iranian 

uranium centrifuges.

Limited in conventional military clout, Israel - believed to 

possess the Middle East's only nuclear arsenal - would prefer to 

see the U.S. superpower lead the way militarily against Iran if 

diplomacy fails.

Yet Israelis watched worriedly as Obama stumbled in his bid 

to muster domestic support for attacking Syria in reprisal over 

Damascus's suspected use of chemical weapons on Aug. 21.

Netanyahu will be looking for proof of Obama's commitment to 

confront Tehran with what the hawkish Israeli premier calls a 

"credible military threat." Obama has insisted he is not 

bluffing, though he has not been as explicit as Netanyahu wants.

However, neither does Netanyahu look any closer to launching 

a strike on Iran alone, with Israeli public support lacking and 

questions about whether it would be militarily effective.

In the meantime, Obama's engagement with Iran could be 

limited by the influence of the pro-Israel lobby in Washington 

and lawmakers who share Netanyahu's suspicion of Rouhani, a 

moderate cleric who took office in August. Netanyahu could meet 

supporters on Capitol Hill as he normally does on U.S. visits.

Seeking to stress common ground between Obama and Netanyahu, 

U.S. national security adviser Susan Rice told CNN on Sunday  

the United States, Israel and other allies "have been largely 

united in agreeing on the process going forward" with Iran.

But she acknowledged that the path was unclear 

as negotiations with Iran were not yet under way.

Further complicating matters is Obama's reinvigorated push 

for a peace deal between Israel and the Palestinians in talks 

that restarted earlier this year. Middle East diplomacy is 

expected to figure more prominently in Monday's meeting than 

originally thought, after Obama listed it as a top priority in 

his address to the United Nations on Tuesday.

           

 

HISTORY OF STRAINED TIES

Obama and Netanyahu have a history of difficult encounters, 

including a blowup in the Oval Office in 2011 when Netanyahu 

famously lectured the president on Jewish history.

Iran strategy has strained relations between them before, 

most notably last year when Netanyahu issued veiled criticism of 

U.S. pressure on Israel not to launch its own pre-emptive attack 

on Iran's nuclear sites.

Having secured a second term, Obama visited Israel in March, 

where he eased a personal rift with Netanyahu and offered  

reassurances that he was determined to deny Iran the means to 

make a bomb, something that Tehran denies it is seeking.

But different clocks tick for the two allies. While they 

agree that Tehran could make its first nuclear device in months 

if it were intent on doing so, Israel publicly warned last week 

that this gap could shrink to weeks, thanks to new Iranian 

uranium centrifuges.

Limited in conventional military clout, Israel - believed to 

possess the Middle East's only nuclear arsenal - would prefer to 

see the U.S. superpower lead the way militarily against Iran if 

diplomacy fails.

Yet Israelis watched worriedly as Obama stumbled in his bid 

to muster domestic support for attacking Syria in reprisal over 

Damascus's suspected use of chemical weapons on Aug. 21.

Netanyahu will be looking for proof of Obama's commitment to 

confront Tehran with what the hawkish Israeli premier calls a 

"credible military threat." Obama has insisted he is not 

bluffing, though he has not been as explicit as Netanyahu wants.

However, neither does Netanyahu look any closer to launching 

a strike on Iran alone, with Israeli public support lacking and 

questions about whether it would be militarily effective.

In the meantime, Obama's engagement with Iran could be 

limited by the influence of the pro-Israel lobby in Washington 

and lawmakers who share Netanyahu's suspicion of Rouhani, a 

moderate cleric who took office in August. Netanyahu could meet 

supporters on Capitol Hill as he normally does on U.S. visits.

Seeking to stress common ground between Obama and Netanyahu, 

U.S. national security adviser Susan Rice told CNN on Sunday  

the United States, Israel and other allies "have been largely 

united in agreeing on the process going forward" with Iran.

But she acknowledged that the path was unclear 

as negotiations with Iran were not yet under way.

Further complicating matters is Obama's reinvigorated push 

for a peace deal between Israel and the Palestinians in talks 

that restarted earlier this year. Middle East diplomacy is 

expected to figure more prominently in Monday's meeting than 

originally thought, after Obama listed it as a top priority in 

his address to the United Nations on Tuesday.

           

 

Find Al Jazeera America on your TV

Get email updates from Al Jazeera America

Sign up for our weekly newsletter

Get email updates from Al Jazeera America

Sign up for our weekly newsletter