Israel accuses UN official of anti-Semitism

Israel’s ambassador to the UN unsuccessfully tried to get Jordanian Rima Khalaf suspended on similar charges in the past

Israel's Ambassador to the U.N. Ron Prosor is urging the its internal watchdog to investigate Rima Khalaf, the head of the U.N. Economic and Social Commission for Western Asia, for misconduct, accusing her of “modern day anti-Semitism.”

Prosor met Carmen Lapointe, the head of the Office of Internal Oversight Services, late last month and called for a disciplinary hearing against Khalaf, a Jordanian. The Economic and Social Commission for Western Asia is based in Beirut and promotes economic and social development in 17 Arab countries.

A July 27 letter from Prosor to Lapointe obtained Wednesday by The Associated Press said “Ms. Khalaf has abused her position in order to promote an anti-Israel agenda, in a flagrant violation of U.N. obligations and principles.”

Khalaf told AP on Wednesday that she stands by her statements highlighting “Israel's documented violations of international law against the Palestinian people” and rejecting “the concept of religious or ethnic purity of states.”

“I am surprised that rejecting discrimination and reiterating the principles of equality and justice in the U.N. charter can still be contested by anyone,” she said.

Prosor gave a series of examples, including her support for the June 29 “illegal and provocative attempt” to break Israel's naval blockade of the Gaza Strip, a July 7 reference that he said equated “terrorism with a fight for justice” and what he called “a hate-fueled report” on Arab integration in March 2014 “that once again promotes anti-Israel incitement by blaming Israel for shortcomings in the Arab world.”

“Ms. Khalaf's outrageous criticism against the state of Israel and the discrediting of its government undermine the integrity of the United Nations and amount to serious misconduct, by U.N. standards,” he said in the letter. “I call on you to initiate an urgent investigation into this matter.”

Lapointe said late Wednesday, when asked whether her office would investigate, that her office “is not allowed by our mandate to discuss whether or not it has opened a case or the status of a case that may have been opened.”

Last year Israel urged the Ban to suspend Khalaf for anti-Israeli statements, but he refused.

In a speech in February 2014, Khalaf referred to “Israel’s adamancy that it is a Jewish state, which violates the rights of both the Muslim and Christian indigenous populations and revives the concept of state ethnic and religious purity, which caused egregious human suffering during the 20th century.”

Prosor strongly objected to her reference to Israel practicing religious and ethnic purity like the Nazis in World War II and to “the appalling claim” in the March 2014 report that Hitler sought to facilitate the emigration of German Jews to Palestine when he was responsible for the murder of 6 million Jews.

Khalaf said she did not claim that Hitler sought to create a safe haven for the Jewish people in the Middle East.

“Nothing is comparable to the atrocities of the Nazis, especially the Holocaust,” Khalaf said. “Yet this should serve as a reminder for the world of the disastrous consequences of discriminating among people based on their religion or ethnic origin.”

Israel's U.N. mission said Prosor told Lapointe during their meeting that “Israel is already fighting against hate and incitement in enough arenas every day” and “will not remain silent” about Khalaf's remarks.

The Associated Press

Related News

Find Al Jazeera America on your TV

Get email updates from Al Jazeera America

Sign up for our weekly newsletter


Get email updates from Al Jazeera America

Sign up for our weekly newsletter