[View the story "'Cancer envy' campaign from UK sparks controversy" on Storify ]'Cancer envy' campaign from UK sparks controversy Critics say efforts of pancreatic cancer organization marginalize other forms of disease. Storified by AJAMStream · Thu, Feb 06 2014 14:50:05
I wish I had...panact
The negative reaction to the ad caused PCA to issue
a statement , arguing that the campaign encourages early diagnosis and will help to improve the disease's 3 percent survival rate. The statement also acknowledged the devastating consequences of other cancers:
All types of cancer are horrific and no one would wish for themselves or anyone they care about to be affected by this terrible disease. Our hearts go out to anyone who has been affected by it.pancreaticcanceraction.org
Ali Stunt, the organization's founder and CEO, also addressed the controversy in a
blog post , citing pancreatic cancer's low survival rate, as compared to other forms of cancer with much higher survival rates. Stunt explained her own experience going through chemotherapy with a friend who had breast cancer and having "cancer envy."
She wrote, "I couldn't help but think every now and then, 'it’s alright for you, you have an 85% chance that you will still be here in five years time – while my odds are only 3%.'
twitter.com
Nonetheless, many believed the campaign was insensitive to those surviving with other forms of cancer. One cancer survivor
wrote , "Cancer is not a competition. It is not a contest to see who has the best or worst experience."
The campaign sparked a debate on social media. Some were quick to criticize PCA:
Still not sure what symptoms of pancreatic cancer r. Only thing more aware of now is the heinous phrase "cancer envy" http://t.co/dNplQ1PgKUSeporah Raizer
@Salon @embeedub Brilliant. As a professor of patient advocacy, these "comparisons" of cancer do nothing to advance treatment.Jean Anne Cipolla
The appalling logic of #CancerEnvy seems a natural consequence of the rise of professional cancer marketing. It's a thing.Kate Bowles
Others expressed support for PCA and the opportunity to create awareness:
Well Done & Thanks @OfficialPCA for drawing attention to the awful disease that so cruelly took my Aunty's life just 3weeks from diagnosis!Olivia Pepall
@OfficialPCA absolutely love your 'controversial' ad. demonstrates exactly why we are in desperate need of research and funding!Mia Franziska Lord
@KerryLou2013 @OfficialPCA agreed. my 29yr old sister might have survived, rather than the 6 weeks she had, if awareness of PC was better!The Switch Project
@OfficialPCA its 1 of least known cancers but kills so easily & rapid. Do what u got to raise awarness. Might save lives . Good luck.eileen carroll
On the PCA site, one supporter applauded the organization for employing "shock tactics:"
Sometimes shock tactics are the only way to get the message across. It is long overdue that pancreatic cancer is shown to be the horrific killer that it is. No one wishes any cancer on anyone but there has been too little known about pancreatic cancer. Some people haven’t even heard of the pancreas, let alone where it is in the body or how crucial it is to health.pancreaticcanceraction.org
How do you feel about the PCA campaign? Leave a comment below.
Error
Sorry, your comment was not saved due to a technical problem. Please try again later or using a different browser.