Fracking protest leads to bigger debate over indigenous rights in Canada

A single campaign in the country's smallest province is now a flashpoint for land rights of First Nations communities

The protests in New Brunswick inspired solidarity protests across Canada earlier this month, such as this trio on traditional drums in front of Parliament Hill in the Canadian capital of Ottawa.
Maike Eikelmann/APTN

MONTREAL — It’s a single shale gas exploration project in one of Canada’s smallest provinces, but it has become a flashpoint in the debate over indigenous land rights in the country.

What began this summer in a small encampment near the Elsipogtog First Nation in New Brunswick has triggered a broader movement with a groundswell of support across the country.

After protesters in New Brunswick set up another blockade last week on a highway near a seismic testing site, demonstrations were held in solidarity in cities across the country. Activists contend this is only the beginning of a lengthy battle in New Brunswick – and part of a larger fight over the stewardship of the country's natural resources.

Elsipogtog — along with the Mi’kmaq indigenous who are part of that nation — has come to represent the struggle for indigenous self-determination, land rights and environmental protection, said Clayton Thomas-Muller, an activist and organizer of the aboriginal movement Idle No More, which took hold last year in Canada.

“It very quickly could set off a firestorm given the current political climate in Canada with Idle No More,” Thomas-Muller said

For now, protesters in Elsipogtog expect a period of quiet, at least over the holiday season.

SWN Resources, a shale gas testing company based in Texas, announced last Friday it had completed its initial round of testing.

Protesters report the company’s high-powered, specialized trucks have left the area and its workers have gone home

But no one is under the impression the company is gone for good.

How will it play out?

A child holds a poster at a demonstration in Barriere Lake, Quebec, where the Algonquin community is protesting the clear-cutting of forests near their community.

“They're probably hoping that morale and the movement will slow us down,” said Suzanne Patles, a Mi'kmaq woman originally from neighboring Nova Scotia, who has been on the protest's front lines since June.

“If the company is gone, everybody is going to strategically plan out their actions.”

A spokeswoman for SWN Resources declined a request for details on its plans for New Brunswick. The statement said only that the company “is pleased to announce that we have completed our seismic acquisition program in New Brunswick.”

defense fund has been set up to help pay for a legal battle with the company, and another for the 13 protesters who were sued for damages by the company.

Meanwhile, similar disputes over land rights are unfolding elsewhere in the country.

In Barriere Lake, Quebec, an Algonquin community is protesting the clear-cutting of forests near their community.

Across the country in Alberta, the Lubicon Lake First Nation is suing an oil and gas company for “the destruction of its traditional lands.”

But it's Elsipogtog that has garnered the most attention, and activists say they are anxious to see how the dispute plays out.

Aboriginal land rights

The protests made headlines when police raided the encampment in October, enforcing a court injunction against a blockade.

Many believe the underlying issue of indigenous land rights in Elsipogtog could have an enduring impact elsewhere.

Prime Minister Stephen Harper's Conservative government is banking on the support of aboriginal communities while working toward his stated goal of making Canada an “energy superpower.”

There are plans, for instance, to build more pipelines carrying oil sands bitumen and natural gas through Alberta and British Columbia, but many of them need to pass through aboriginal territories.

A new report by a Harper-appointee outlines how to “forge relationships” with aboriginals. It advises the government to focus on “building trust, fostering inclusion, and advancing reconciliation.”

In that respect, there appears to be quite a lot of work to do.

A full one-third of aboriginal Canadians have “zero” trust in the country's oil and gas companies, according to a recent survey. The same survey suggests some are willing to talk about resource development if it's shown to be beneficial to them.

In New Brunswick, the Mi’kmaq have argued the exploration work is being conducted on land that they never ceded to the crown when they signed treaties with the British in the 18th century.

New Brunswick's government granted SWN licenses to explore for shale gas four years ago in exchange for investment in the province worth approximately CA$47 million (about US$44 million).

Larry Chartrand, a law professor at the University of Ottawa, said disputes over aboriginal land rights appear to be increasingly common – though it’s difficult to predict how each will end.

“Sometimes it's settled pretty quietly, with some incentives for the (aboriginal) bands, other times the conflict escalates,” said Chartrand, an expert in aboriginal rights.

Fault Lines on Al Jazeera America

Photos out of Elsipogtog

In Fault Lines' episode "Elsipogtog: The Fire Over Water," Wab Kinew traveled to Mi’kmaq territory in New Brunswick, Canada to ask why the fight against fracking in the area caught fire. 

Here are some images from the episode capturing the clash and the calm.

Read More

A little history

Thomas-Muller said he sees parallels between Elsipogtog and another First Nations protest over land rights held two decades ago.

In 1990, real-estate developers in the town of Oka wanted to extend a golf course onto an ancestral Mohawk burial ground.

In what became known as the Oka Crisis, the Mohawks barricaded a road leading to the development that summer. The government countered with an intervention from police and, eventually, the Canadian military.

“On a broader geopolitical context, Elsipogtog has emerged as the Oka of the Harper Conservative administration,” Thomas-Muller said.

“They're trying to use force instead of diplomacy, trying to erase democratic freedoms in the interest of defending corporations.”

One province westward, a similar dispute over traditional territory is underway involving the Algonquins of Barriere Lake.

Barriere Lake's Chief Casey Ratt said there have been disagreements with forestry companies since the 1980s, when he was a boy.

This year, Ratt said he feels more optimistic about the fight.

“The community is trying to accomplish one thing – that we get properly consulted on areas that are within our traditional territories,” he said.

“They've taken enough resources out of this territory without giving anything back to the community.”

New Brunswickers skeptical

In New Brunswick, which has one of the highest unemployment rates in the country, the provincial government has tried to present shale gas as an economic generator.

But opinion polls suggest many New Brunswickers remain skeptical.

Opponents fear that shale gas extraction by means of hydraulic fracturing, or fracking, would contaminate the environment, especially the ground water. The process involves injecting water and chemicals into shale rock to release gas deposits trapped inside.

Neighboring Quebec, as well as New York, have introduced moratoriums.

The protests in New Brunswick aren't limited to the Elsipogtog First Nation. Anglophones and Acadians have also taken part in demonstrations.

According to Patles, New Brunswickers worried about fracking see the benefits of aligning themselves with aboriginal protesters from the Elsipogtog First Nation, who argue they have a right to consultation over natural resources.

“The people who are not indigenous are invoking upon the indigenous people for help because of our treaty rights,” Patles said.

“They have reached out to the indigenous people to say we need help.”

Related News

Find Al Jazeera America on your TV

Get email updates from Al Jazeera America

Sign up for our weekly newsletter


Get email updates from Al Jazeera America

Sign up for our weekly newsletter